An early morning vehicle fire in rural Indiana has unraveled into a case prosecutors describe as a calculated and brutal killing — one that left a 58-year-old man beaten, shot, and burned inside his own car.
Amy Singhas, 43, of Indiana, is now facing a sweeping list of felony charges in connection with the December death of her boyfriend, Michael Greer. According to court records reviewed by Law&Crime, Singhas has been charged with murder, arson resulting in serious bodily injury, kidnapping, criminal confinement, obstruction of justice, and conspiracy to commit murder.
Greer’s death came to light in the early hours of Dec. 14, 2025. At approximately 3:45 a.m., the Delaware County Sheriff’s Office received a report of a vehicle fire in a rural field about 60 miles northeast of Indianapolis. When deputies arrived, they found a car fully engulfed in flames. As firefighters extinguished the blaze, authorities made a grim discovery: a body inside the vehicle.
That body was later identified as Greer.
Family members told Indianapolis NBC affiliate WTHR that Greer had been in a relationship with Singhas before his death. What investigators allege happened next paints a grim and violent picture.
According to law enforcement, Greer was attacked at a home in Indianapolis. Authorities say he was beaten and shot before being wrapped in fabric and placed in the back seat of his own car. He was then allegedly transported to the rural Delaware County field where the vehicle was set on fire.
An autopsy revealed a harrowing detail: Greer was still alive when the flames engulfed the car.
Ten days after the fire, the Delaware County Sheriff’s Office issued a press release announcing multiple arrests. Alongside Singhas, then-23-year-old Ameariss Aponte was taken into custody. Aponte faces charges including murder, arson, and obstruction of justice.
Investigators allege that the plan to dispose of Greer’s body involved Singhas initially driving the car to the field with Greer in the back seat. At some point, Aponte allegedly got into the driver’s seat and drove the vehicle off the road before it was set ablaze. Authorities say both individuals admitted to aspects of the plan.
The case, however, does not stop with two defendants.
At least three other people have also been charged in connection with Greer’s death: 43-year-old Tallis McCoy, 39-year-old Randal Moon Jr., and 30-year-old Megan Sloan. Each faces charges including murder, arson, and obstruction of justice. Sloan has since been ruled incompetent to stand trial, while proceedings continue for the others as the case works its way through the court system.
Despite the numerous arrests, one major question remains unanswered: motive.
Law enforcement has not publicly disclosed what may have prompted the alleged attack. There has been no official statement outlining a financial dispute, domestic altercation, or other clear trigger. The absence of an identified motive has left observers searching for context in a case already marked by shocking violence.
For Greer’s loved ones, the legal process unfolds alongside profound grief.
In his obituary, Greer is remembered not for the way he died, but for the way he lived. “He touched the hearts of everyone who had the privilege of knowing him,” the tribute reads. It goes on to describe his “unwavering love for his family and friends, a love that guided his actions, inspired his generosity, and reflected the strength of his heart.”
That portrait stands in stark contrast to the allegations now before the court.
Singhas is scheduled to appear for a pretrial hearing on March 16, with a jury trial currently set for May 12. Prosecutors will have to prove not only that she participated in the events leading to Greer’s death, but that she did so with intent — a central element in the murder charge.
